Painful Fingers

A Guide For Diagnosis, Treament and Referrals

Follow the steps below to get your diagnosis

The Process

Go through steps 1-3 to find out what that painful finger could be:

(the icons 1 – 3 are clickable to to take you to the appropriate place in the page)

1.

Distinguish where exactly the finger pain is coming from

2.

Are there visible clues?

3.

Suggestions and Red Flags

1: Distinguish where the pain is coming from:

Tenderness over the first joint in the finger (PIPJ)

  • Arthritis (synovitis)
  • Gout

Tenderness over the tendons on the front

  • Inflammation (tenosynovitis)
  • ?infected (Red Flag)

Tender over terminal joint (DIPJ)

  • Arthritis
  • Mallet injury (drooping tip)
  • Infection (felon or paronycia)
  • Tender and lump ?mucous cyst
  • .Mainly tender on the front with no active flexion at the tip = rugger jersey finger (Flexor pull off)

Pain only on moving the finger

  • Arthritis
  • Trigger finger
  • Infection in tendon sheath (Red Flag)
  • Generalised swelling (peripheral oedema, post-op, injury)
Differential diagnoses in the fingers

2: Are there visible clues?

Lumps

Mucous / Myxoid cyst

Mucous cyst – associated with underlying arthritis

Infection?

Kanavel's signs of Flexor sheath infection

Kanavel’s signs of flexor sheath infection (Red Flag++)

A Felon in the pulp space – needs incision and drainage

Paronychial infection of the finger

Paronychial infection – may need incision and drainage

Do they have active movement at the DIPJ?

Mallet finger

Mallet (middle) finger

3: Suggestions and Red Flags:

Choose the most likely diagnosis of the finger pain for more information e.g. when to refer.

Mucous cyst

Mucous / Myxoid cyst

Mucous cyst

(Also called Digital Myxoid Cyst)

Key Symptoms: A small, fluid-filled lump on the finger, usually near the nail or end joint, smooth and round, may be translucent, can be painful if it presses on a nerve.

Best Test: Palpate the lump for a fluid-filled consistency.

Brief Description: A mucous cyst is a benign sac filled with joint fluid that arises from the distal interphalangeal joint.

Possible Causes: Associated with osteoarthritis of the finger joint, when an ostephyte pokes through the capsule and allows fuild to come out.

What Can I Do as a GP?: Reassurance (often harmless), avoid puncturing the cyst (risk of septic arthritis), refer to a hand surgeon if the cyst is bothersome, painful, or interferes with every day life.

Red Flags for Urgent Referral: Rapidly growing mass, associated with pain, numbness, or tingling, signs of infection (redness, warmth, fever).

What Can Ali Offer: Surgical excision of the cyst is relatively easy, under local anaesthetic. Most often performed if the underlying arthritis is NOT painful. If PAIN is a predominent feature of the DIPJ then fusion of the joint is preferred.

Gout

Gout

Key Symptoms: Sudden onset of severe finger pain, redness, swelling, and warmth in one or more finger joints, often starting at night. Joints may be exquisitely tender to touch. +ve Hx of gout.

Best Test: Usually present with existing gout in other joints – Blood tests may also show elevated uric acid levels.

Brief Description: Gout is a type of inflammatory arthritis caused by a buildup of uric acid crystals in the joints. It can affect any joint, but often starts in the big toe or fingers.

Possible Causes: High levels of uric acid in the blood due to diet (high in purines), alcohol consumption, certain medications, kidney problems, or genetic predisposition.

What Can I Do as a GP?: Prescribe anti-inflammatory medications (NSAIDs) or colchicine for acute attacks, refer to a rheumatologist for long-term management and prevention. All the normal stuff!

Red Flags for Urgent Referral: Suspicion of septic arthritis (joint infection), severe pain and inflammation not responding to initial treatment, underlying medical conditions (e.g., kidney disease).

What Can Ali Offer: I can help with the diagnosis and management of gout in the fingers, particularly if there are complications like tophi (uric acid crystal deposits) or joint damage. In severe cases, surgery may be necessary to remove tophi or repair damaged joints.

Paronychia

Paronychial infection of the finger

Paronychia

Key Symptoms: Redness, swelling, and tenderness around the nail fold (the skin surrounding the nail), pus may be present under the skin, throbbing painful finger.

Best Test: Examine the affected finger for signs of inflammation, pus, and tenderness around the nail fold.

Brief Description: An infection of the skin around the nail, usually caused by bacteria or fungus.

Possible Causes: Hook nail or ingrown nail, nail biting, frequent exposure to water or chemicals, diabetes.

What Can I Do as a GP?: If mild, warm soaks and topical antibiotics may be sufficient. If severe or associated with diabetes, refer to me for drainage of the abscess and IV antibiotics.

Red Flags for Urgent Referral: Spreading infection (red streaks extending from the finger), fever, diabetes, immunocompromised state.

What Can Ali Offer: Incision and drainage of the abscess if necessary, culture and sensitivity testing, appropriate IV antibiotic therapy.

Felon

Felon

Key Symptoms: Severe, throbbing pain in the fingertip pad, swelling, redness, warmth, and tenderness. The finger may be held in a slightly bent position due to pain.

Best Test: Examine the fingertip for signs of infection (redness, swelling, warmth, tenderness). Gentle palpation may reveal a fluctuant abscess (pus-filled collection).

Brief Description: A felon is a bacterial infection of the fingertip pulp (the soft tissue at the end of the finger). It can be very painful and may lead to serious complications if not treated promptly.

Possible Causes: Puncture wound, splinter, hangnail, other minor trauma to the fingertip that allows bacteria to enter.

What Can I Do as a GP?: Refer the patient to a hand surgeon for urgent evaluation and treatment.

Red Flags for Urgent Referral: Severe finger pain, swelling, redness, warmth, fluctuance (pus collection), fever, signs of spreading infection (red streaks), diabetes.

What Can Ali Offer: Incision and drainage of the abscess if necessary, culture and sensitivity testing, appropriate IV antibiotic therapy.

Mallet Injury

Mallet finger

Mallet Injury

Key Symptoms: Inability to actively straighten the tip of the finger, drooping of the fingertip, painful finger and tenderness at the back of the DIP joint (end joint of the finger). History of sudden drooping.

Best Test: Ask the patient to straighten the fingertip. Inability to do so indicates a mallet finger. Any doubt, resist the extension and the pt will be unable to.

Brief Description: A mallet finger is caused by a rupture of the extensor tendon at the end joint of the finger. This prevents the fingertip from straightening.

Possible Causes: Direct blow to the tip of the finger (e.g., ball striking the fingertip), forced bending of the finger.

What Can I Do as a GP?: Splint the fingertip in extension (straightened) to prevent further deformity and refer to a hand surgeon. Patients MUST not remove the splint for 6-8 weeks!

Red Flags for Urgent Referral: All cases…especially open wound, fracture associated with the mallet finger, significant pain or swelling or late presentation >1 week.

What Can Ali Offer: Splinting the DIP joint in full extension for 6-8 weeks is often successful in healing the tendon but it is more about education I can provide. In some cases, surgery may be needed to repair the tendon or reattach it to the bone.

Rugger Jersey Finger

Rugger Jersey Finger

Key Symptoms: Inability to actively bend the tip of the finger, pain and tenderness at the base of the finger on the palm side, finger may appear straight or even slightly extended. Always associated with sudden loss of flexion.

Best Test: Ask the patient to bend the fingertip. Inability to do so indicates a rugger jersey finger, especially against resistence. Check for tenderness at the base of the distal phalanx on the palm side.

Brief Description: Rugger jersey finger occurs when the flexor digitorum profundus (FDP) tendon, which bends the tip of the finger, is avulsed from its attachment on the distal phalanx.

Possible Causes: Forced extension of a flexed finger (common in sports like rugby when a player grabs another player’s jersey).

What Can I Do as a GP?: Refer urgently to a hand surgeon for evaluation and management.

Red Flags for Urgent Referral: Inability to bend the fingertip, pain at the base of the distal phalanx on the palm side.

What Can Ali Offer: Surgical repair of the FDP tendon is necessary. Early treatment is crucial for the best outcome.

DIPJ Arthritis

Arthritic DIPJ

DIPJ Arthritis

Key Symptoms: Pain, stiffness, and swelling in the end joint of the finger, decreased range of motion, bony enlargement of the joint, may develop Heberden’s nodes (bony lumps on the end joint).

Best Test: Examine the DIP joint for tenderness, swelling, and decreased range of motion. X-rays can confirm the diagnosis of OA. It is usually obvious associated with older age and lumps on the finger tip joint.

Brief Description: Wear-and-tear arthritis affecting the end joint of the finger. It can cause pain, stiffness, and deformity.

Possible Causes: Age-related degeneration, previous injury to the joint.

What Can I Do as a GP?: Advise activity modification, splinting (straight), over-the-counter pain relief (e.g., ibuprofen, naproxen), and refer to a hand surgeon if symptoms persist or worsen.

Red Flags for Urgent Referral: Severe pain or loss of function, significant deformity, suspicion of inflammatory arthritis.

What Can Ali Offer: I can replace or fuse any of the finger joints, under local anaesthetic, with minimal time off work etc.

I love treating arthritis. They are some of the most appreciative patients when I take their pain away!

PIPJ Arthritis

PIPJ Arthritis

Key Symptoms: Painful finger, stiffness and swelling in the middle joint of the finger, decreased range of motion, bony enlargement of the joint, may develop a Boutonniere deformity (bending of the middle joint and hyperextension of the end joint) and Bouchard’s nodes.

Best Test: Examine the PIP joint for tenderness, swelling, and decreased range of motion. X-rays can confirm the diagnosis of OA.

Brief Description: Wear-and-tear arthritis affecting the middle joint of the finger. It can cause pain, stiffness, and deformity.

Possible Causes: Age-related degeneration, previous injury to the joint, inflammatory arthritis.

What Can I Do as a GP?:  Advise activity modification, splinting, over-the-counter pain relief (e.g., ibuprofen, naproxen), and refer to a hand surgeon if symptoms persist or worsen.

Red Flags for Urgent Referral: Severe pain or loss of function, significant deformity (e.g., Boutonniere deformity), suspicion of inflammatory arthritis (Rheumatology referral).

What Can Ali Offer: I can replace or fuse ALL of these joints! I love treating arthritis. The patients are so appreciative afterwards!

Ligament Injury

Ligament Injury

Key Symptoms: Painful finger, swelling and bruising usually on the sides (over the ligaments) of the middle joint of the finger. Associated with limited range of motion and most often a sudden injury.

Best Test: Examine the PIP joint for tenderness, swelling, deformity, and abnormal movement. X-rays are often needed to rule out fractures and assess joint alignment.

Brief Description: Injury to the ligaments that support the PIP joint, ranging from a mild sprain (stretching) to a complete rupture or dislocation.

Possible Causes: Trauma (e.g., stubbed finger, sports injury), forceful bending or twisting of the finger.

What Can I Do as a GP?: If a simple sprain is suspected, buddy tape the injured finger to the adjacent finger and get the finger moving! Do not immobilise. Buddy to the finger on the same side as the side that is MORE painful. 

If dislocation is present, attempt gentle reduction (realignment) of the joint if possible. Refer to a hand surgeon for further evaluation and management if patient is unable to move the finger or you suspect it may still be misaligned.

Red Flags for Urgent Referral: Dislocation that cannot be reduced, open wound, significant deformity, Delayed presentation >2 weeks.

What Can Ali Offer: Splinting or buddy taping for minor sprains. For severe sprains, ruptures, or dislocations, surgery may be needed to repair or reconstruct the ligaments.

Tenosynovitis of Flexor Tendons

Flexor tenosynovitis

Tenosynovitis of Flexor Tendons

Key Symptoms: Painful finger, swelling and tenderness along the path of the flexor tendon in the finger or palm, triggering or catching sensation when bending or straightening the finger, stiffness, finger may lock in a bent position.

Best Test: Palpate for tenderness and swelling along the flexor tendon sheath. Check for triggering or locking of the finger with movement.

Brief Description: Inflammation of the sheath surrounding the flexor tendons in the finger. It can cause pain, swelling, and difficulty moving the finger smoothly.

Possible Causes: Overuse or repetitive strain of the finger, inflammatory conditions (e.g., rheumatoid arthritis), infection.

What Can I Do as a GP?:  Advise rest, splinting, ice, and over-the-counter pain relief (e.g., ibuprofen, naproxen). Refer to a hand surgeon if symptoms persist or worsen.

Red Flags for Urgent Referral: Signs of infection (fever, redness, warmth, pus), persistent triggering or locking, rapidly worsening symptoms.

What Can Ali Offer:  Corticosteroid injection into the tendon sheath can be useful if infection is ruled out, hand therapy is a mainstay. In severe or persistent cases, surgery (tenolysis – excision of the tenosynovium) may be needed.

Summary:

Painful fingers are incredibly common. There are 2 million people in the UK suffering with painful arthritis alone. I can replace or fuse ALL PIPJ or MCPJs and fusion of the DIPJ for pain is a fantastic way to get people out of pain.

Most finger injuries can be mobilised but some cannot! It is really difficult to tell clinically which ones can and which ones can’t so if you are in any doubt PLEASE refer as picking up the pieces is much more difficult to deal with.

If you have any questions, please call me! I have a Business WhatsApp number: 07448339269 Or open directly in the Footer

It is much more important to the patients that they get the very best specialist opinion as early as possible and if I can help in that, please just text away.

Why me?

My goal is simple – to get patients back to normal life as quickly as possible, with decisions that they are comfortable with. I involve them every step of the way and I believe I can provide a standard of care unmatched in this area.

Five Star
Reviews

Committed to

Patient Education

Video Consultation Available

Wide Awake Hand Surgery

Quick Recovery

Thumb Joint Replacements

I prioritise non-operative solutions whenever possible, relying on a collaborative approach with expert Hand Therapists. Surgery is a last resort, and when it’s necessary, I ensure we discuss all options, with a preference for minimally invasive techniques and the latest proven and evidence-based innovations like the joint replacement for the base of the thumb.

Arrange a consultation

If you need my help with a difficult case or one that you feel could do with an opinion from a specialist, then please get in touch.

This will trigger an email conversation directly with me! We can then see if the patient needs to see me face to face or if I can educate you to be able to deal with them.

[wpforms id="2037"]
Ali Phillips - Orthopaedic Hand & Wrist Surgeon in Hampshire

Disclaimer:

The information provided on this page is for educational purposes only, is a guide and is not a substitute for professional medical advice. If you have any concerns about a specific patient’s hand or upper extremity condition, please consider referring them to Ali Phillips for specialist evaluation and treatment.